A flight bound for New York City is held hostage by Libyan-sponsored terrorists for 16 hours. Twenty passengers are shot and killed; 100 severely injured. A child had to clamber over the body of her dead father in order to escape the carnage.
That child who survived the 1986 hijacking of Pan Am Flight 73, along with scores of other American victims of Muammer el-Qaddafi’s state-sponsored terrorism, still awaits compensation from the Justice Department’s Foreign Claims Settlement Commission. And the FCSC’s Libya Claims Program is running out of money.
A 2008 settlement agreement between the Bush administration and Qaddafi was supposed to end lengthy litigation over the Qaddafi regime’s assets. Instead, the deal that dismissed the federal court cases of American victims and referred them to the FCSC has sparked a new fight.
Tapping the deposed dictator’s frozen assets, advocates for the victims say, would be the best way to address the commission’s funding shortfall.
The problem though, is the fledgling Transitional National Council wants that money, too.
“The TNC believes this matter was fully resolved” back in 2008, said David Tafuri, a lawyer at the Washington firm Patton Boggs who represents the TNC in Washington. Tafuri said the TNC believes that American claimants need to bring their complaints to the U.S. government, rather than asking for Libya’s money.
Assets totaling $33 billion linked to the regime have been frozen by the U.S. alone since Libya’s democratic uprising began. The TNC has argued that all the former regime’s assets should be channeled into humanitarian and nation-building projects in Libya.
American victims of state-sponsored terrorism have been able to file suit against foreign governments since 1996, and since 2000 there have been cases where courts or Congress have tapped frozen assets in order to compensate victims. What Qaddafi’s American victims are asking for isn’t unprecedented, but Libya has become a special case.
The 2008 settlement deal, signed into law by the Libyan Claims Resolution Act, removed terror-related cases against the Qaddafi regime from federal courts in exchange for $1.5 million, provided by Qaddafi. Because of that settlement, Qaddafi’s victims receive awards according to a strict formula laid out by the State Department. The FCSC does the paperwork; it doesn’t set the policy.
To let awards go unfulfilled “would be inconsistent with congressional intent expressed in the 2008 Libyan Claims Resolution Act and would be fundamentally unfair, particularly since these victims can no longer seek redress in federal court,” said nonvoting Rep. Pedro Pierluisi, D-Puerto Rico.
Mary Kathyrn Hasset lost her youngest daughter, Margaret, when Libyan-sponsored terrorists hijacked UTA Flight 772. Margaret was on her way home after serving two years in the Peace Corps when her Paris-bound flight exploded over the Sahara desert.
“For years I thought, what can I do?” Hassett said of the time after her daughter’s death. Joining with other victims of UTA 772 to sue Libya made her feel like she had the “personal ability to hold Qaddafi accountable.”
The UTA 772 victims won their court case, Pugh v. Libya. But they never saw a dime of the multimillion-dollar court judgment. Before an appeal to the decision could be resolved, the settlement agreement was finalized. Hassett is still waiting for the FCSC to award her and her daughter’s estate the amount the State Department recommended.
The agreement between Bush and Qaddafi erased a growing source of concern for both Libyan and American businesses: litigation against Qaddafi’s regime. Terror-related lawsuits not only hurt the Libyan dictator and his cronies, but also made American businesses working with the oil-rich nation vulnerable.
Bush agreed to drop all litigation against the Qaddafi regime if Qaddafi provided enough money to satisfy the existing claims of American citizens against him. Then-Secretary of State Condolezza Rice assured Congress that the $1.5 billion Qaddafi provided would be enough to compensate everybody. It was supposed to be a win-win for all concerned.
The $1.5 billion was distributed in stages. The State Department immediately compensated the most high-profile victims, those affected by the 1988 Lockerbie hijacking and the 1986 bombing of German nightclub La Belle Discoteque. The estates of those killed in Qaddafi’s attacks—including Margaret’s estate-- each received $10 million.
The remaining victims—like Hassett, her other children, Margaret’s father, and the survivors and families of Pan Am 73— were referred to the FCSC. The State Department divided the claimants into categories and described awards appropriate for each category. It was understood that funds would be divided up on a pro-rata basis if the $1.5 billion started to run low.