| Left-leaning (19 votes) | Right-leaning (17 votes) | ||||||||
![]() |
![]() |
||||||||
|
|
||||||||
|
VERY LIKELY "He's probably one of the smartest men to ever get elected, and his chances of rising to the occasion are great -- not just relatively (compared to what preceded him, almost anyone with an ounce of good faith would look good), but on an historic scale, as well." Howie Klein, Down With Tyranny! "Not only is he involving a large cross-section of opinion in his plans, including some skill at the skill positions, he is involving the public (who understand the difficulty of the tasks that lie ahead). The previous guy played only to the base, lied to the public, and we know how that worked out." Greg Dworkin, Daily Kos "Let's say that the economy continues to tank for the next two years, as it's been forecasted. If Obama can at least reverse most of Bush's imperial executive orders as well as pull out of Iraq, that would be enough to make his presidency successful." Liza Sabater, CultureKitchen "Lots of challenges, but he seems to be the sort of person the country needs: committed to making government work, to innovation and to collaboration." Tracy Viselli, Reno And Its Discontents "I really hate to make assessments of his administration before it has actually started. There is too much anticipating. Everything Barack Obama does and says is being overanalyzed to a point way past absurdity. That said, I think he has the intelligence and leadership skills to make real progress." Barbara O'Brien, The Mahablog "If he can continue to reach across the aisle in Congress, stay connected to the grassroots and share the credit for accomplishments, he can have a successful presidency." Matt L. Barron, RuralVotes "Difficult times can produce excellent presidents. Or not, as in the case of George W. Bush." Robert Farley, Lawyers, Guns And Money SOMEWHAT LIKELY "I think some people are just so excited to be out of the Bush era that anything will seem better. But I worry that he won't live up to the expectations." Maegan la Mala, VivirLatino "Obama is likely to have large majorities in both houses of Congress for the entirety of his first term. How he chooses to use those majorities will go a long way toward determining how successful he will be. He should look toward accomplishments, more than simply accommodating Republicans for the sake of a perceived bipartisanship." Brian Leubitz, Calitics "Obama's biggest obstacles: 1) Obstructionist Senate Republicans; 2) Harry Reid's fecklessness in dealing with them; 3) Entrenched corporate interests, which badly want things like health care reform and card-check to fail." David NYC, Swing State Project "He has quite a mess to clean up, and somehow the Republicans will find a way to pin it on him." Susie Madrak, Suburban Guerrilla SOMEWHAT UNLIKELY "Judging by his current Cabinet appointments, the next two years at least are going to be Clinton-era 'triangulation' and there will be no real progressive reform. Foreign policy will also be a mess, as AIPAC and what's left of the neocons will prevent Obama from talking to the Iranians in any meaningful way." Sean-Paul Kelley, The Agonist |
VERY LIKELY "He will be a successful president because eventually the economy will recover. It really won't make any difference if his actions had any effect or not, he will still get credit for it. The media that was so remarkably incurious about his dubious political connections or questionable fundraising will deflect most criticism away from him. I suspect that he's also smart enough not to ruin his reputation by engaging in risky behavior like Bill Clinton did." David Gerstman, Soccer Dad SOMEWHAT LIKELY "'Likely' is a term that will be ultimately defined by the media. As most in the media adore him, President Obama (and even Chris Matthews said it's their job to see to it) will 'do' just fine." Bob Parks, Black And Right "His party holds both houses of Congress -- what could go wrong? :-)" J.R. Hoeft, Bearing Drift SOMEWHAT UNLIKELY "It depends on the yardstick. He has the opportunity to be great because he's facing huge economic and global crises. Both of those have the ability to destroy him, though, as he is unlikely to be able to 'fix' the economy in time for his re-election bid." James Joyner, Outside The Beltway "Many of his appointments suggest that he could exceed the pessimistic view of conservatives who saw him as a hard leftist. We know he can run a campaign; we don't yet know how well he can run the executive branch. He will be tested early by Iran, Venezuela and/or Russia; if he lets them bully him, he will become a one-term failure like Carter." David Kopel, The Volokh Conspiracy "He's already demonstrating that he leads from behind, floating gracefully from one position to another in a determined effort to satisfy all polling constituencies. For him, the 'vision thing' is defined by his own popularity on a daily basis, and that seems to me to be the antithesis of leadership." Bookworm, Bookworm Room "The Middle East and the economy will prove to be Obama's undoing." D.S. Hube, The Colossus Of Rhodey "He has a lot going for him, but he also takes office at a terribly difficult time. Things will get a bit worse before they get better. If he deals with the economy OK, he will be considered a good president. It is likely that the economy will improve before the end of his first term." Michael van der Galien, PoliGazette "Like Bill Clinton, Obama will be a political success only if he accepts limited policy ambitions and distances himself from his party in Congress." Dan McLaughlin, Baseball Crank "The presidency is a challenge, driven many times by outside events no one predicts. Some, like the current occupant of the White House, simply don't measure up to what gets thrown at them. Will Obama? I doubt it, but time will tell." Robert Miller, JoshuaPundit VERY UNLIKELY "His decision-making ability appears to be inadequate, and, like the Chicago-style politician he is, always includes an 'out.' A waffler will bring a Carter second term -- the last guy to hold the office in a near-constant state of paralysis. It will take more than references to Abe Lincoln to actually be an Abe Lincoln." Doug Lambert, GraniteGrok "I think Obama is in over his head. When he walks into the Oval office for the first time, I hope he has a 'come to Jesus moment' realizing the responsibilities that now are on his shoulders." Debbie Hamilton, Right Truth "Raising taxes and government spending during a recession has a long and storied history of failure. It's too bad Obama can't learn from it." Rob Port, Say Anything |
| Left-leaning (19 votes) | Right-leaning (17 votes) | ||||||||||
![]() |
![]() |
||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||
|
TERRIBLE "Just as Benedict Arnold became an icon of treason, as long as there is an America, George W. Bush will be an icon of something. However, I'm not sure if the final lasting impression will be his incompetence, his corruption, his smarmy cockiness or the partisan rancor he enabled and encouraged. If there's a word that combines all of those qualities, that's what Bush will be an icon of." Barbara O'Brien, The Mahablog "Worst president in history. Bush supporters say history will vindicate him. I think he will be judged even more harshly as time goes by." Ellen Brodsky, News Hounds "The statehouse's golden dome here in New Hampshire is shining a little brighter these days because Franklin Pierce, often labeled the worst president in the history of the republic, now has some terrific competition for that spot." Dean Barker, Blue Hampshire "Most of us won't even live to see the day that America will have undone the harm done to this nation by this administration. And that makes me despise not just his acts, but the man." Lee Papa, The Rude Pundit "Not only did Bush erode America's standing abroad, as well as at home, he disrespected the rule of law, placed loyalty above competency, and tarnished the reputation of some stellar federal agencies (NASA, FEMA, DOJ and CDC immediately come to mind), did nothing to assist the Middle East set up any kind of process for peace (the number of SoS visits doesn't count, outcomes do), and got us into the Iraq quagmire on a lie about WMD. How much worse can it get? Hearings would tell us, but we're not likely to go there." Greg Dworkin, Daily Kos "There are really no highlights to the Bush administration from where I stand politically. None. What. So. Ever." Liza Sabater, CultureKitchen "Stubborn refusal to admit mistakes and listen to other points of view and really bad appointments add up to worst president ever." Matt L. Barron, RuralVotes "Worst president ever to serve two full terms." Robert Farley, Lawyers, Guns And Money "Worst. President. Ever. Two wars, an economic collapse and the ever-shrinking middle class are all signs of a devastation wreaked upon America over the past eight years. Just digging out of the hole that the failed conservative legacy has left us will take years." Brian Leubitz, Calitics "The worst president ever. Period." Sean-Paul Kelley, The Agonist "When you allow a born loser with a lifetime record of failure to take over the presidency, why expect anything different from the catastrophe George Bush has given America?" Howie Klein, Down With Tyranny! "From war lies to hate crimes, we certainly haven't entered a post-racial era, but at least we don't have Bush." Maegan la Mala, VivirLatino "I saw an event on Facebook called 'The End of an Error.' I think that's putting it mildly." Tracy Viselli, Reno And Its Discontents "Some truths are self-evident. Just awful." Susie Madrak, Suburban Guerrilla |
GOOD "He got the big thing correct. He saw the danger of Islamism and brought the fight to America's enemies. After 9/11 he realized, unlike Bill Clinton, that there was no vacation from history. Unfortunately, he did a poor job of selling his program and allowed a partisan and hostile media to define him in conjunction with his political opponents." David Gerstman, Soccer Dad "His efforts in the war against Islamic terror have been excellent. I have not been happy with him when it comes to illegal immigration or government spending." Debbie Hamilton, Right Truth "He said all along that we would fight abroad to keep the fight from coming here. With no attack on America since 9/11, how can you fault this policy?" J.R. Hoeft, Bearing Drift "It was President Bush's job to keep America safe. To the best of his ability, he did." Bob Parks, Black And Right "No successful terrorist attacks since 9/11. Overall good performance on domestic policy, with the exception of spending out of control. His worst major idea (semi-amnesty for illegal aliens) was, fortunately, not enacted." David Kopel, The Volokh Conspiracy FAIR "He got a second term, which precludes it from falling into the worst categories. If Iraq continues its progress, he could advance into the 'good' category in the eyes of history. It's hard to see how he moves up to 'great,' though, absent a spectacularly bad job by his successor." James Joyner, Outside The Beltway "Bush has many accomplishments, and some of those (like Iraq) will hopefully survive Obama's efforts to undo them. His greatest weakness was never understanding the importance of publicly defending his own record. Ironically, given the prosperity of most of his term, history is more likely to vindicate Bush's foreign policy than his economic record." Dan McLaughlin, Baseball Crank "His biggest mistake was going against his 2000 campaign pledge of 'no nation-building.' Not to mention he presided over a GOP Congress that spent money like drunken sailors. Success? We were not attacked again after 9/11." D.S. Hube, The Colossus Of Rhodey "On the one hand, he was successful in shoring up our defenses and preventing more terror attacks following 9/11, which trumps everything else in importance. He was terrible, however, at 'leading' the nation in its aftermath. In democratic countries, war cannot be sustained without maintaining the support of the people. The lack of leadership also sunk his domestic programs." Doug Lambert, GraniteGrok "He got a lot of things right (war on terror, Middle Eastern policy, tax cuts) and a lot of things really wrong (bailouts, expansion of entitlements). He was mediocre. At best." Rob Port, Say Anything "Poor guy got dealt a terrible hand. He was outstanding on national security, pretty good (until panic set in) on the economy, dreadful on immigration, and average on a host of other issues. An honorable man, though, and that's something to be said considering the corrupt administration the preceded him (and that will probably follow him, too)." Bookworm, Bookworm Room POOR "He made too many mistakes. He did not govern conservatively and responsibly enough." Michael van der Galien, PoliGazette TERRIBLE "One of the four worst presidents in U.S. history according to the criteria of actual harm done to the country, along with Clinton, Carter and James Buchanan." Robert Miller, JoshuaPundit |