Skip Navigation

Close and don't show again.

Your browser is out of date.

You may not get the full experience here on National Journal.

Please upgrade your browser to any of the following supported browsers:

Stephen Trachtenberg Is Not Sorry Stephen Trachtenberg Is Not Sorry

NEXT :
This ad will end in seconds
 
Close X

Not a member? Learn More »

Forget Your Password?

Don't have an account? Register »

Reveal Navigation
 

 

Restoration calls: Education

Stephen Trachtenberg Is Not Sorry

Students have more debt than ever before. But the university president who helped propel a tuition arms race says schools are just getting started.

+

Defiant: “I would have been bolder,” Trachtenberg says of his spending spree.(Richard A. Bloom)

CORRECTION: A previous version of this story misidentified Jeff Denneen.

Shortly after Stephen Trachtenberg announced in 2007 that he would step down as president of George Washington University, he strolled alone from his office to the school’s library, where he often held informal office hours at the adjoining Starbucks. He bought a cup of coffee and sat at a table outside, contemplating his success.

 

The valedictory beverage felt well earned. Since Trachtenberg took over in 1988, he had boosted the school’s endowment from $250 million to $1 billion and built many state-of-the-art facilities, such as computer and research labs. The profusion of comforts didn’t just stimulate students’ minds; it also fulfilled their every whim—a change that drew a more selective, more intelligent group of applicants and sent the admission rate plummeting from 75 percent to 37 percent. “It was a very soothing, very beautiful experience and gave me a great sense of satisfaction about my tenure as president,” Trachtenberg wrote in his memoir, Big Man on Campus.

Trachtenberg’s students funded this triumph. When he became president, they paid $25,000 (in today’s dollars) in tuition, room, and board to attend; by the time he retired, they paid $51,000. Trachtenberg made George Washington the most expensive school in the nation. The burst of cash powered his agenda, but the freshmen who borrowed to enroll—46 percent of the class—during his final year graduated with an average of $28,000 of debt.

Trachtenberg also set a trend that other colleges—first his private competitors, then universities across the country—felt compelled to follow. Today, George Washington is only the 21st most expensive school, and the average American student accumulates $24,300 of debt earning her diploma. Collectively, Americans hold more student-loan debt than credit-card debt, and graduates enter a world where more than half of them are jobless or underemployed.

 

A recession requires austerity, and Trachtenberg concedes that the charge-more/spend-more model cannot continue in today’s economy. “I don’t think the current model can go on,” he says, pointing out that schools can’t spend when their cash reserves run low.

But his misgivings go only so far. He still swears by the system he built, and he believes that the economy will improve to accommodate universities’ ambitions before schools have to scale back in response to the slowdown. If he has any regrets about his presidency, it is that he wishes he had pushed his board harder to spend more. “I would have been bolder,” Trachtenberg says. “I devoted too much time and energy worrying about a rainy day.”

“Some folks—well-meaning idealists—act as if their undergraduates are just brains without bodies.” — Ben Sasse, Midland University president

In a world where reputation and endowment are the most tangible—and therefore the most important—measures of scholastic success, Stephen Trachtenberg’s vision for higher education is a glimpse of the debt-driven future.

 

THE LURE

Trachtenberg himself chose Columbia University when he graduated from high school. He remembers feeling impressed by its “international repute,” “academic gravitas,” and “sense of serious scholarship.” He did not mind that all it took to fill his dorm room was an armoire, two desks, and a bunk bed he shared with his roommate, Ted Small. Trachtenberg took the top bunk, Small took the bottom, and the two were content to be dry when it rained and warm when it snowed.

Trachtenberg was an only child, and his father was a life-insurance salesman in Brooklyn who could pay for only about half of the $816 annual tuition. Trachtenberg paid the difference and covered his living expenses by delivering The New York Times during the school year and waiting tables in the Catskills during summers. The college gave some aid based on need, but Trachtenberg got none. Still, he remembers being surrounded by students from both elite and working-class families at Columbia.

He graduated in 1959. After acquiring a law degree from Yale and a master’s in public administration from Harvard, he eventually spent 11 years as president of the University of Hartford. When he moved to Washington to take over at George Washington, it was a school with a relatively meager endowment that accepted the overwhelming majority of applicants.

DON'T MISS TODAY'S TOP STORIES
Sign up form for the newsletter

But students had changed since he and Small shared their hovel. Now they expected more from their schools—and they were willing to pay more for it. “It was a matter of competition,” Trachtenberg says in the way of justifying the suite-style dorms he built, the remote campus he acquired, and the tuition hikes that he began almost immediately. “These sorts of facilities were being offered elsewhere. We were either in the game or we weren’t in the game.”

Trachtenberg’s opponents weren’t Columbia, Yale, or Harvard. They were other private universities with similar profiles. He looked at U.S. News & World Report to see where else his applicants had sent their SAT scores and discovered that his peers were Emory, Tulane, Syracuse, Boston University, and New York University. Each is a large urban school now ranked between 20 and 50 by the magazine’s annual college survey. (George Washington is 51.)

This article appears in the September 29, 2012 edition of National Journal Magazine.

DON'T MISS TODAY'S TOP STORIES

Sign up form for the newsletter
Comments
comments powered by Disqus
 
MORE NATIONAL JOURNAL