Skip Navigation

Close and don't show again.

Your browser is out of date.

You may not get the full experience here on National Journal.

Please upgrade your browser to any of the following supported browsers:

Would the Confederacy Have Celebrated the Fourth of July? Would the Confederacy Have Celebrated the Fourth of July?

This ad will end in seconds
 
Close X

Not a member? Learn More »

Forget Your Password?

Don't have an account? Register »

Reveal Navigation
 

 

Policy

Would the Confederacy Have Celebrated the Fourth of July?

July 4, 1861, was a day of ambivalence for many Southerners.

Aboard a Confederate gunboat captured on July 4, 1862.(Library of Congress)

"It is like the anniversary of a divorced couple's wedding."

That's how a reporter in the New York Times described July 4, 1861, the first Independence Day of the Civil War. And much like a failed marriage, it was unclear which side would retain what was once shared. Should the Confederacy have their own July Fourth as well? After all, without the initial breakaway from Britian, their revolution wouldn't be possible.

The writer—an ur-David Brooks of sorts—continued in a thought experiment: What might a Confederate Fourth of July celebration look like?

 

It would be simply the old one, such as we have been accustomed to all our lives, and then a sequel directed against the United States. Liberty, independence, British oppression, Colonial misgovernment, would appear in their old places, and then would come "Part the Second," consisting of indignant complaints against the Free-soilers, and their violation of Southern rights, joined together like the landing at Torbay and the Gun-powder Plot in the service we have alluded to. The tyrants of the old speeches would do duty again with a new one added. It will now be King GEORGE, Lord NORTH, and President LINCOLN.

Like the shared biblical figure Abraham in Islam, Judaism, and Christianity, the Founding Fathers would make it into the founding sagas of each country. The story would diverge from there.

In a 2009 paper in the Journal of Southern History, historian Paul Quigley wrote that while some Southerners were conflicted with celebrating the holiday, acknowledgement of the day continued on. In Charleston, S.C., he points out, a specially appointed five-member committee decided that "public procession, solemn oration, and political banquet ought to be omitted on the present occasion," but offices would would be closed for the Fourth.

Before the war, the meaning of the holiday was already taking on different flavors. In the North, abolitionists used its language of freedom to call for the end of slavery. In the South, secessionists used its language of willful rebellion to call for a new state, inciting that the North had not lived up to the Declaration of Independence's promise. Quigley goes on to explain how the Fourth of July ambivalence was "part of their attempt to resolve tensions between southernness and Americanness."

But most importantly, the Fourth of July represented a shared celebration and an identity the North and South could rejoin after the war.

During the first half of the nineteenth century, Independence Day settled into a less overtly partisan occasion. Celebrations took standardized forms: the ringing of bells and the firing of salutes; the closing of businesses and stores ... the reading aloud of the Declaration; and the consumption of food and alcohol.'

In their very uniformity, these rituals constituted important elements of early American nationalism, in the South as well as the North. This was the day of the year when, according to numerous reports, the American people were supposed to forget their differences and come together in a unified celebration of their great nation.

So maybe the Fourth of July saved the Union, or at least provided a basis for a renewed national identity after reconstruction. "They had separated from the central government formed by the American Revolutionary generation but wished to claim the heritage of that generation," Quigley wrote.

And when the war was over, that heritage was something they could still hold on to. The divorced parents got back together.

Job Board
Search Jobs
Digital and Content Manager, E4C
American Society of Civil Engineers | New York, NY
PRODUCT REVIEW ENGINEER
American Society of Civil Engineers | CA
Neighborhood Traffic Safety Services Intern
American Society of Civil Engineers | Bellevue, WA
United Technologies Research Fellow
American Society of Civil Engineers | New York, NY
Process Engineering Co-op
American Society of Civil Engineers | Conshohocken, PA
Electrical Engineer Co-op
American Society of Civil Engineers | Findlay, OH
Application Engineer/Developer INTERN - Complex Fluids
American Society of Civil Engineers | Brisbane, CA
Application Engineer - Internships CAE/CFD Metro Detroit
American Society of Civil Engineers | Livonia, MI
Chief Geoscientist
American Society of Civil Engineers
Application Engineer - Internships CAE/CFD Metro Boston
American Society of Civil Engineers | Burlington, MA
Professional Development Program Engineer
American Society of Civil Engineers | Farmington Hills, MI
Civil Enginering Intern - Water/Wastewater/Site-Development
American Society of Civil Engineers | Sacramento, CA
Staff Accountant
American Society of Civil Engineers | Englewood, CO
Biomedical Service Internship Position
American Society of Civil Engineers | Flint, MI
 
Comments
comments powered by Disqus