Before Colorado and the rest of America move on from last Friday's theater massacre, before all the satellite trucks and national reporters return to their homes, before the politicians stop preaching and the preachers stop politicking, I'd just like to ask a quick question of President Obama, presumptive Republican nominee Mitt Romney, and any federal or state elected official who wants to chime in. But first a few stipulations:
Fact 1: In a piece titled "Assessing the Trade-Offs Between Security and Civil Liberties," The New York Times on Tuesday tells us that the national-security apparatus in the U.S. today is so extensive that no fewer than 4.86 million people in the United States have some form of "security clearance" as part of the nation's response to the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.
Fact 2: In the same piece, The Times' Scott Shane reports: "In return for the bulked-up surveillance and the costly security industry boom, some counterterrorism officials would say the nation has gotten a good deal: There has been nothing even close to a repeat of 9/11. Islamic extremists have killed 14 people in the United States since 2001, 13 of them in the shooting spree by an Army psychiatrist at Fort Hood, Texas, in 2009."
Fact 3: Last month, the National Counterterrorism Center issued its 2011 report. Its drafters concluded that "17 U.S. private citizens worldwide were killed by terrorist attacks in 2011" and that "14 U.S. private citizens were wounded by terrorism in 2011." In the NCTC's 2010 report, those figures were 15 killed and nine wounded.
Fact 4: Last year, around the anniversary of the terrorist attacks, David Sanger of The Times estimated the cost of America's counterterrorism program after 9/11 to be $3.3 trillion. On Tuesday, my Atlantic colleague Steve Clemons put the figure at $2.7 trillion for just defense spending alone. Let's agree, whatever the exact figure, that it's an awful lot.
Fact 5: According to 2008 statistics, compiled by the CDC's National Center for Injury and Violence Prevention and Control and chronicled by the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence, 31,593 people died in America as a result of gun violence. Of those, 12,179 people were murdered. Nearly 3,000 children died as a result of gun violence that year, and another 66,749 people were injured.
Fact 6: According to 2009 statistics, again compiled by the CDC, 31,147 were killed in the U.S. by firearms. Of this figure, 11,493 were murdered. The Brady Campaign estimates that 334,182 people have been killed by gun violence since the Twin Towers fell.
Fact 7: In Colorado on Friday, a lone gunman, armed with an assault rifle, body armor, and gas grenades, killed 12 people and wounded 58 more. Last month, during a single weekend in the city of Chicago, eight people were killed and 45 wounded as a result of gun violence. Approximately 33 people are murdered each day in America.
Fact 8: According to a 2011 CRS Report, from fiscal 2001 to fiscal 2010 "Congress increased direct appropriations for the ATF by 50.2 percent, from $771 million to $1.158 billion.... The proposed FY2011 firearms program allocation accompanying the administration's budget request is $837.4 million, or 72 percent of the FY2011 budget request ($1.163 billion)." In the end, Congress evidently approved an ATF 2011 budget of $1.113 billion. For fiscal 2012, that number evidently is $1.152 billion. (ATF puts the increase at only 45 percent over the period, and says the appropriations through 2010 came to $1.115 billion).