Political Pulse

By William Schneider

"Political Pulse" is Bill Schneider's take on politics and public opinion.

William's Recent Stories:

Stay Connected

POLITICS

Tough Luck For Big Business

The American public is saying: No more bailouts.

Updated: February 16, 2011 | 9:09 a.m.
April 18, 2009

In 1953, General Motors President Charles Wilson told a Senate committee, "For years, I thought what was good for our country was good for General Motors and vice versa. The difference did not exist. Our company is too big. It goes with the welfare of the country."

Does the public believe that today? No. In a CNN poll taken this month by Opinion Research, more than three-quarters of Americans said that if GM and Chrysler need more government money, Washington should rebuff them. In other words, let 'em go bankrupt. That is the same thing most of the public is saying about banks and financial institutions: No more bailouts.

GM Chief Executive Fritz Henderson, who replaced ousted CEO Rick Wagoner, is thought to be more open to a possible bankruptcy filing. "By no later than June 1," Henderson said, "if we're not able to accomplish this -[restructuring] outside of bankruptcy, then we'd be in bankruptcy. We don't need any more time in order to get this done."

Do Americans think that if automobile companies went bankrupt it would cause a crisis or major problems for the economy? In December, two-thirds thought that it would. Now, not so many: 47 percent feel that it would cause a crisis or major problems, while 53 percent say it would cause minor problems or no problems at all.

As former business executive and Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney pointed out, "A number of us said that bankruptcy or a bankruptcy-like process was something that was needed to get GM and Chrysler on their feet again."

But would Americans buy a car from a company in bankruptcy? Only 37 percent said they would. Enter Mr. Goodwrench. Make that, President Goodwrench. "If you buy a car from Chrysler or General Motors, you will be able to get your car serviced and repaired, just like always," President Obama announced on March 30. "Starting today, the United States government will stand behind your warranty."

Most people say if automakers need more money, Washington should say no.

Will that make a difference? You bet. In the CNN poll, 57 percent said they would consider buying a new car from a bankrupt company if the federal government stood behind the warranty.

When the Obama administration pressed for the resignation of GM's Wagoner, it faced criticism that the government was going too far. As management consultant Vince Crew, author of Everyday Ethics, Everlasting Consequences, put it, "When it comes to dismissing a CEO, that's the job of a company board, not the president of the United States." Obama tried to sound cautious. He reassured the public that "the United States government has no interest in running GM, and we have no intention of running GM."

Washington is now subjecting 19 large banks that have received federal loans to stress tests to determine whether they could survive a deeper economic downturn. The results will be announced within the next three weeks. Bank executives are worried that the Obama administration will insist on changes in management and strategy, such as limits on executive pay, merger demands, debt-reduction requirements, and restrictions on hiring foreigners. Some banks are paying back bailout funds to escape the restrictions.

Does the public think that Obama has gone too far in getting the federal government involved in the way businesses are run? Only 35 percent say that he has. -Instead, most Americans feel that the -president's actions have been about right (42 percent) or have not gone far enough (23 percent).

The criticism appears to reflect ideology. Seventy percent of Republicans think that Obama has gone too far in regulating business. Only 9 percent of Democrats agree. Democrats are more likely than Republicans to say that if the auto companies went bankrupt, it would create major problems for the economy. Republicans are supposed to be the -pro-business party, but Democrats have fewer inhibitions about letting the federal government bail out troubled -corporations.

Republicans are more likely than Democrats to complain about Big Government. But right now, public anger is focused more on the abuses of Big Business. Actually, the people don't trust either Big Government or Big Business. That's why Americans don't like the idea of bailouts: They are viewed as Big Government colluding with Big Business.

This article appeared in the Saturday, April 18, 2009 edition of National Journal.

Want to stay ahead of the curve? Sign up for National Journal’s AM & PM Must Reads. News and analysis to ensure you don’t miss a thing.

Join the Discussion
The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.
Comments powered by Disqus
Follow National Journal
  • NationalJournal on Twitter
  • NationalJournal on Facebook
  • NationalJournal on Tumblr
  • NationalJournal's RSS Feeds
  • NationalJournal's Email Newsletters
  • NationalJournal on iPhone and iPad
COLUMNS
Gwen Ifill: Gwen's Take

Election 2012 – Managing Alternatives

5:06 p.m.

In politics, the language of choice often comes loaded. School choice. Abortion rights. Public option. Proponents embrace these descriptions to put the best possible face on otherwise contentious issues. This was one of the weeks when the politics of alternatives defined the debate. 

Charlie Cook: Charlie Cook's The Cook Report

Right and Wrong

2:00 p.m.
A prolonged race could force Mitt Romney to tack even more to the right, which would hurt him in November.
Ronald Brownstein: Political Connections

The Enemy Is Us

2:00 p.m.
Republicans increasingly question government entitlements for the poor, but the big costs remain with the middle class.
More Columns »
The Next Economy

Living Longer Is a Blessing, Not a Curse

Baby boomers are fast becoming elderly boomers, a demographic change that will shape the nation’s society—and its economy—for decades to come.

EXPERT OPINIONS
Transportation Experts

Now We're Getting Political

10:11 p.m.

Latest Response by Bill Lind: Advice for the Ways and Means Chairman

Transportation Experts

Now We're Getting Political

7:14 p.m.

Latest Response by Emil H. Frankel: Enactment Depends on Better Choices

National Security Experts

Should the U.S. End the Combat Mission in Afghanistan in 2013?

12:08 p.m.

Latest Response by James Jay Carafano: War by Calendar

More Expert Opinions »