The Year In Forgettable Candidates

Welcome back to The Hotline's "Year In Review" features. So far, we've brought you the Year In Scandals, the Year In Upsets, the Year In Surprise Stars and the Year In Media.

We now turn to a group of more disappointing contenders -- the most Forgettable Candidates and campaigns of 2010. These spanned the country this year and in most cases, they were highly touted recruits -- Democrat and Republican alike -- who never got their campaigns going.

Think anyone, for example, will remember Tom Emmer? The Republican Minnesota gubernatorial contender couldn't have asked for a better opponent than former Democrat Mark Dayton. Dayton, a generally lackluster retail politician known for his one term in the Senate, wasn't the preferred candidate of most Democrats. But Emmer -- a Tea Party favorite -- proved to be too far to the right for Minnesota and wasn't helped by Independence Party contender Tom Horner. The race was too close to call on Election Day, but Emmer eventually conceded after a month-long hand recount and legal challenges showed he had no chance to overtaking Dayton.

If Emmer got his preferred opponent, so too did Democrat Alex Sink in the Florida governor's race. Attorney General Bill McCollum was most Republicans' preferred nominee, but he lost to businessman Rick Scott (R) in the primary after Scott poured millions into the race. Scott's past business dealings led Democrats to dub him the "Madoff of Medicare" -- something that you'd think would be pretty damaging in a state with as large a senior citizen population as Florida. But Sink had plenty of her own missteps, including apparently cheating during a debate. In the end, Scott and his millions won in what was a major blow to Democrats.

People will remember outgoing Indiana Rep. Brad Ellsworth's 2010 Senate campaign -- but not in a good way. Getting Ellsworth to run for retiring Sen. Evan Bayh's (D) seat was considered a major recruiting accomplishment for Democrats. But that was just about the only bright spot for Ellsworth, who struggled to close Republican former Sen. Dan Coats's double-digit lead. Ellsworth may return, however; his name is being floated as a potential 2012 gubernatorial or Senate contender.

Much like Ellsworth, New Hampshire Rep. Paul Hodes was touted as a top tier Democratic candidate for the New Hampshire Senate race. And, also like Ellsworth, Hodes never seem to get his campaign off the ground. Hodes trailed Republican Kelly Ayotte from the get-go, and it only got worse as Election Day approached. Hodes also didn't raise much money and Ayotte cruised to the Senate after emerging from the Republican primary.

Republicans were elated when former Maryland Gov. Bob Ehrlich (R) announced he would seek a rematch with Gov. Martin O'Malley (D). And Ehrlich appeared to be closing in on O'Malley's early lead, on only to see the Democrat blow it open in last couple months before Election Day. If nothing else, Ehrlich proved just how difficult it is for a Republican to win statewide in Maryland -- which may explain why he said after the election that he was done with politics.


Leave A Comment
The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.
Comments powered by Disqus
Follow National Journal
About

Staff


Reid Wilson, Editor-in-Chief
Steve Shepard, Executive Editor
Julie Sobel, Editor
Kevin Brennan, Deputy Editor


Disclaimer


On Call editors reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments. The Hotline, National Journal Group, Inc. and Atlantic Media Company are not responsible for the content of the comments that remain.