Campaign analysis by the most interesting thinkers in Washington

Time to Get Rid of Caucuses, Let Other States Go Early, Or Both

A caucus participant hands an extra ballot back to a caucus chairman during a Republican caucus meeting, Saturday, Feb. 4, 2012, in Las Vegas. ((AP Photo/Julie Jacobson))

As I write this, it's 24 hours after the TV networks called the Nevada caucuses for Mitt Romney, and more than 13 percent of the vote is still uncounted. When will we know whether Romney topped 50 percent, whether Newt Gingrich or Ron Paul came in second, how the state's 28 delegates will be doled out? Maybe when a flock of carrier pigeons arrives at state party headquarters? This week sometime would be good.

We won't even get into the tiny turnout in Nevada, which was moved up on the nomination calendar four years ago so the West would have an early say in the presidential process. Or the weirdness of an evening caucus that you couldn't get into unless you signed an affidavit about your religion. Or the "trouble box." Seriously.

This can't be what Republican elders envisioned. Nor were they likely expecting the Iowa GOP to announce more than two weeks after its Jan. 3 kickoff caucuses that Romney, declared the winner on caucus night, actually lost to Rick Santorum. Oh, and votes from eight precincts were missing, so who knows who really won.

"The Super Bowl is over but the #NVCaucus isn't," tweeted Craig Robinson, whose Twitter handle is @IowaGOPer, 24 hours after the race was called.

Maybe the dysfunction in Nevada is making him and other Iowans feel better (schadenfreude, anyone?), but Iowa has nothing to brag about. There are two more caucus contests coming up Tuesday in Colorado and Minnesota. If they manage to pull off smooth, high-turnout elections, maybe they should be first in the West and Midwest on the 2016 calendar. Or how about both parties agree to let Arizona go first? It's in the West, it holds a primary, and it may be evolving into a general-election swing state. That's a win-win-win.


Leave A Comment
The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.
Comments powered by Disqus
Follow National Journal
Decoded Contributors
Tim Alberta

Tim Alberta

Editor, Hotline Last Call!

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Caren Bohan

Caren Bohan

Managing Editor for Domestic Policy

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Ronald Brownstein

Ronald Brownstein

Editorial Director

Decoded Posts | All Stories


George E. Condon Jr.

George E. Condon Jr.

Staff Writer, White House

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Matthew Cooper

Matthew Cooper

Editor, National Journal Daily

Decoded Posts | All Stories


John Aloysius Farrell

John Aloysius Farrell

Congressional Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Ron Fournier

Ron Fournier

Editor-in-Chief

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Chris Frates

Chris Frates

Lobbying Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Major Garrett

Major Garrett

Congress Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Shane Goldmacher

Shane Goldmacher

Congressional Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Michael Hirsh

Michael Hirsh

Chief Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Jackie Koszczuk

Jackie Koszczuk

Editor, The Almanac of American Politics

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Josh Kraushaar

Josh Kraushaar

Executive Editor, The Hotline

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Jill Lawrence

Jill Lawrence

Managing Editor, Politics

Decoded Posts | All Stories


James Oliphant

James Oliphant

Deputy Magazine Editor

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Beth Reinhard

Beth Reinhard

Political Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Storie


Alex Roarty

Alex Roarty

Staff Writer, Politics

Decoded posts | All Stories


Lori Santos

Lori Santos

Managing Editor, Breaking News

Decoded posts | All Stories


Jim Tankersley

Jim Tankersley

Economics Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Reid Wilson

Reid Wilson

Editor-In-Chief, The Hotline

Decoded Posts | All Stories