Campaign analysis by the most interesting thinkers in Washington

Newt's Tough on Iran, Syria. How's That Gonna Work?

Short of reading from the Torah, Republican presidential candidates will appear before Jewish voters today and do just about everything they can to pander. Democrats pander, too, but each party has its own spiel. The GOP line is pretty clear: Obama's too soft on Iran and Syria. (They'll also get into settlements and Hamas but let's leave that aside for a minute.)

Frontrunner (!) Newt Gingrich has vowed to get tougher on Syria and all of the candidates have waxed tough on preventing Tehran from getting nukes. The big exception here is Ron Paul who isn't coming before the Republican Jewish Coalitiontoday and whose libertarian, no-foreign-aid-or-entanglements line wouldn't be welcome. 

But how can President Gingrich really get tougher? The George W. Bush administration avoided a military confrontation with Iran and so far the Israelis have too for all of the obvious reasons. Can you even get the centrifuges and other equipment if you decide to dispatch bombers? What of the consequences in the region to everything from Iraqi destabilization to oil flow? No one wants a nuclear-armed Iran but if it were easy to prevent that we would have done it already.

As for Syria, the Libyan experience should be a cautionary tale. First, it took the U.S. and the allies a lot longer to help bring Qaddafi down than anyone at first thought. And now that he is down, what will follow remains to be seen. The sheer military venture was not easily executed. 

And that was a multilateral affair. The U.S. famously chose to lead from behind. This time, there's no European enthusiasm for a military adventure over the skies of Damascus which means we'd have to make it our war. The Arab League may have ostracized Assad but they've shown no inclination to send their American-made arms into Syrian territory. 
Between Kurdish-Turkish tentions, Iraq's shaky democracy and an irritible Iran, do we want to launch a third war on the Eurasian continent? Perhaps getting rid of Syria's Assad will be easier than anyone thought but anyone waxing tough should plan on it being just he opposite. 

Would be delighted if you followed me on Twitter @Mattizcoop

Leave A Comment
The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.
Comments powered by Disqus
Follow National Journal
Decoded Contributors
Tim Alberta

Tim Alberta

Editor, Hotline Last Call!

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Caren Bohan

Caren Bohan

Managing Editor for Domestic Policy

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Ronald Brownstein

Ronald Brownstein

Editorial Director

Decoded Posts | All Stories


George E. Condon Jr.

George E. Condon Jr.

Staff Writer, White House

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Matthew Cooper

Matthew Cooper

Editor, National Journal Daily

Decoded Posts | All Stories


John Aloysius Farrell

John Aloysius Farrell

Congressional Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Ron Fournier

Ron Fournier

Editor-in-Chief

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Chris Frates

Chris Frates

Lobbying Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Major Garrett

Major Garrett

Congress Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Shane Goldmacher

Shane Goldmacher

Congressional Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Michael Hirsh

Michael Hirsh

Chief Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Jackie Koszczuk

Jackie Koszczuk

Editor, The Almanac of American Politics

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Josh Kraushaar

Josh Kraushaar

Executive Editor, The Hotline

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Jill Lawrence

Jill Lawrence

Managing Editor, Politics

Decoded Posts | All Stories


James Oliphant

James Oliphant

Deputy Magazine Editor

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Beth Reinhard

Beth Reinhard

Political Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Storie


Alex Roarty

Alex Roarty

Staff Writer, Politics

Decoded posts | All Stories


Lori Santos

Lori Santos

Managing Editor, Breaking News

Decoded posts | All Stories


Jim Tankersley

Jim Tankersley

Economics Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Reid Wilson

Reid Wilson

Editor-In-Chief, The Hotline

Decoded Posts | All Stories